Seed Saving vs. Self-Sowing

Seed Saving vs. Self-Sowing

What I Collect and What I Let Nature Plant

One of my favorite things about gardening is letting nature paint its own picture in my garden.

Every spring at Scout Hill Farm in Hollis, New Hampshire, I find little seedlings popping up in unexpected places. Some are exactly where I want them. Others need to be moved around or simply weeded out. And occasionally, something appears that I completely forgot I grew the year before (think tomatoes)!

Over the years, I've developed a pretty simple approach to saving seeds. Some plants I collect seeds from every fall, others I leave to self-sow, and a few I do both with.

It's an easy way to save money, grow more plants, and create a garden that feels a little more natural and spontaneous.

One important note: these are my observations from gardening in Southern New Hampshire (Zone 6). Self-sowing depends on much more than hardiness zone alone. The length of your growing season, first frost date, soil conditions, and even how frequently you harvest a plant all influence whether its seeds will mature. A plant described as an aggressive self-seeder in one region might barely produce seeds in another!

Here's what I do in my garden.

1. The Seeds I Collect Every Fall

These are generally plants that aren't reliably winter-hardy in New Hampshire, or ones I want to start indoors to get a head start on the growing season.

Zinnias, Cosmos, and Marigolds

These are some of my favorite annual flowers, and they're incredibly easy to save seeds from.

I let a few of the best flowers fully mature and dry on the plant, then collect the seed heads before they deteriorate in wet fall weather.

A few things to know:

Zinnias: I collect seeds from my favorite blooms, although varieties can cross-pollinate, so seedlings may not look exactly like their parents.

Cosmos: These are particularly easy to save, and sometimes they'll surprise me by self-sowing the following spring.

Marigolds: Let the flower heads dry thoroughly, then pull apart the heads to reveal the long, slender seeds.

I store the seeds somewhere cool and dry until I'm ready to start them the following spring.

Basil

Basil is another plant I love collecting seeds from. I grow most of my basil for cut flowers vs. eating, so I usually allow them to go to flower. Lemon, cinnamon and thai basil are my favorites.

If you let basil flower and mature, it produces plenty of tiny black seeds. Once the flower spikes have turned brown and dry, you can strip the seeds from the stems.

I like saving seeds from plants that were particularly vigorous or productive.

Just remember that different basil varieties can cross-pollinate, so saved seeds don't always produce identical plants. This might matter more for folks eating the basil.

Pumpkins, Cucumbers, and Squash

Saving seeds from vegetables is especially satisfying because you're collecting next year's crop from this year's harvest.

I save seeds from fully mature pumpkins, cucumbers, and squash.

The biggest consideration with these vegetables is cross-pollination.

Many squash varieties can cross with others of the same species, so saved seeds may produce something quite different from the original vegetable. Cucumbers can also cross with other cucumber varieties.

That doesn't necessarily bother me because I am not growing enough varieties for this to have been an issue for me.

For cucumbers, seeds should be collected from fully mature, usually overripe fruits and fermented before drying. For pumpkins and winter squash, I scoop out the seeds, separate them from the pulp, and dry them thoroughly.

Sweet Peas

Sweet peas are another favorite to save.

Once they've finished flowering, I let some of the pods mature on the vines until they turn brown and papery.

Then I collect the pods, remove the seeds, and store them for next season.

Sweet peas prefer cool weather, so I like having seeds ready to plant early in the season.

2. The Plants I Let Self-Sow

These are the plants I generally don't bother collecting seeds from. Instead, I let them drop their seeds naturally and see what comes up the following year.

Some of these plants are perennials, some are biennials, and some are annuals that can reseed themselves.

Bowman's Root

Bowman's root (Gillenia trifoliata) is a beautiful native perennial with delicate white flowers and airy foliage.

I love the natural look it brings to a garden, and I'm happy to let seedlings establish where they find a good home.

It's not an aggressive self-seeder, so I consider new seedlings a bonus rather than something I count on every year.

I am sending seeds to a friend per her request so we shall see how easy they are to start by hand. They need cold stratification which adds complexity. I will report back on socials!

Foxgloves

Foxgloves are one of my favorite examples of why letting plants self-sow can be so rewarding.

Many common foxgloves are biennial, meaning they grow foliage in their first year, flower in their second, and then die.

But if you let them go to seed, they can create a continuous cycle of new plants.

I love how they appear in unexpected spots and create that loose, cottage-garden feeling.

One caution: foxgloves are highly toxic if ingested, so consider their placement carefully around children and pets.

Tomatoes

Yes, tomatoes!

Anyone who's ever composted a tomato or left fallen fruit in the garden has probably discovered volunteer tomato seedlings the following spring.

I often let a few of these grow just to see what happens.

Of course, volunteer tomatoes aren't necessarily the varieties I planted the year before, especially if they came from hybrids. And in our relatively short New Hampshire growing season, they may get a later start than tomatoes grown indoors.

Still, there's something fun about getting a surprise tomato plant for free.

Greens Like Kale and Lettuce

If you let kale or lettuce flower and produce seeds, there's a good chance you'll discover little seedlings the following season.

Lettuce can be especially generous with its seeds.

Kale is typically biennial, so plants that survive winter may flower and set seed in their second year.

I love letting a few greens finish their life cycle rather than pulling everything out as soon as the harvest is over.

You may find yourself with an unexpected patch of baby greens the following spring!

Verbena bonariensis

Tall verbena is one of those plants that makes a garden look effortlessly beautiful.

Its tall, wiry stems and clusters of purple flowers weave through other plants without blocking the view.

Although it isn't perennial in my climate, it can self-sow beautifully.

I leave the seed heads standing and watch for new seedlings the following spring.

Because the seedlings can be tiny, it's worth learning what they look like before you start weeding!

This entire patch self sowed from 1 plant in a pot!

Korean Agastache

Korean agastache (Agastache rugosa) is a wonderful plant for pollinators, and I love the vertical flower spikes it adds to the garden.

Its not a native of course, but it has lots of benefits and my husband is Korean so it seems fitting.

It's another plant I prefer to let self-sow.

The seedlings can fill gaps and create natural drifts, and I can always move or thin them if too many appear.

Here is a chartreuse foliage version:

3. The Plants I Do Both With

Some plants are so easy to grow from seed that I collect a little for insurance while also allowing them to scatter seed naturally.

Fennel and Dill

These are two of my favorite herbs to let wander around the garden.

Both have beautiful, airy foliage and flowers that attract beneficial insects. They're useful in the kitchen, but I also love incorporating their delicate textures into garden designs and flower arrangements.

I collect some seeds so I can plant them where I want them, but I also leave plenty to fall naturally.

Bronze fennel in particular can be a wonderful self-seeder, popping up in unexpected places the following spring.

Here is a grouping that always wanders this little corner of this bed.

Shiso

Shiso is a little different.

I grow it primarily for its gorgeous foliage, which I cut constantly for flower arrangements. It's one of my favorite foliage crops at Scout Hill Farm!

Because our growing season in Southern New Hampshire is relatively short, shiso barely has time to mature its seeds before frost. And since I'm harvesting it regularly, I don't get nearly as much flowering and seed production as gardeners in warmer climates might.

If I manage to collect mature seeds, I save them, but I certainly don't count on shiso to reseed itself here.

It's a perfect example of why gardening advice needs to be localized. A plant described as an aggressive self-seeder in one region might behave completely differently in another.

I grow both the green and purple varieties (purple pictured below)

Feverfew

Feverfew is another plant I love for both the garden and cut flower production.

Its masses of small, daisy-like flowers are wonderful for adding texture and a light, airy feeling to arrangements.

Feverfew can be a generous self-seeder, so I often leave some flowers to mature and scatter their seeds naturally.

I also collect seeds to start new plants where I want them, especially when I'm planning my cutting garden for the following season.

One of the things I love about feverfew is how easily it can tuck itself into little gaps in the garden. It's a great example of a plant that can be both productive and beautiful without requiring much fuss.

I prefer the open centered variety vs. the frilly double ones.

Annual Rudbeckia

Annual and short-lived rudbeckias, particularly Rudbeckia hirta and its colorful cultivars, are another group I love to experiment with.

Some years I collect seeds from my favorite flowers. Other years I leave the seed heads standing and let the plants do their own thing.

The fun part is seeing what comes back.

If you're growing multiple colors or varieties, seedlings can look quite different from the parent plants. That can be especially exciting when you enjoy unusual colors and flower forms.

I also love leaving rudbeckia seed heads standing through winter for the birds.

4. My Simple Seed-Saving Process

You don't need much equipment to start saving seeds.

Here's my general process:

  1. Choose healthy plants. I select vigorous plants with flowers, foliage, or fruit that I particularly liked.
  2. Let the seeds mature. For most flowers and herbs, I wait until the seed heads or pods have turned brown and dry.
  3. Collect on a dry day. I try to avoid harvesting wet seed heads, which can be more prone to mold.
  4. Dry the seeds thoroughly. I spread them on paper or in shallow containers somewhere dry with good airflow. Fleshy-fruited crops need their own seed-cleaning methods first.
  5. Label everything! I write down the plant name, variety if known, and year collected.
  6. Store somewhere cool, dark, and dry. Paper envelopes work well for organizing seeds, and thoroughly dried seeds can be kept in airtight containers to protect them from moisture. I also use ziplock bags as long as the seeds are very dry.

One thing I've learned: always label your seeds immediately. It's amazing how quickly a collection of little brown seeds becomes impossible to identify! I take ziplock bags and sharpies around the yard and label as I collect.

Tip: If you want to collect a seed but dont know when it will be ripe, use an organza bag over the seed pod and let the seeds fall into the bag on their own. Make sure the flowers are pollinated and forming seeds BEFORE you put the bag on.

5. A Few Things to Know About Self-Sowing

Letting plants self-sow is one of my favorite ways to create a more natural garden, but there are a few things to keep in mind.

Learn to recognize seedlings. If you don't know what your favorite plants look like when they're tiny, you may accidentally weed them out in spring.

Don't mulch too heavily where you want self-sowing. A thick layer of mulch can prevent some seeds from germinating. I leave a few areas with thinner mulch or exposed soil where I want seedlings to establish.

Be willing to edit. Self-sowing doesn't mean letting everything grow wherever it wants. I regularly thin, transplant, or remove seedlings to keep the garden balanced.

Expect surprises. Seed-grown plants, especially those from hybrids or cross-pollinated varieties, may look different from their parents. Sometimes those surprises are the best part.

Consider your local growing conditions. A plant that self-sows enthusiastically in a warmer climate might not have enough time to mature seeds in New Hampshire. The opposite can also be true. Pay attention to how plants behave in your own garden rather than assuming they'll behave the same way everywhere.

Want a garden that feels natural, abundant, and beautiful throughout the seasons?

At Scout Hill Farm in Hollis, New Hampshire, I offer garden design consultations and custom planting plans focused on layered plantings, four-season interest, pollinator-friendly plants, and lower-maintenance gardening.

Visit Scout Hill Farm to learn more about my garden design services.

Back to blog

Leave a comment